PHILADELPHIA (AP) – A federal judge on Monday rejected a lawsuit challenging the “normalization of the race” in the dementia tests of retired NFL players, which some say makes it more difficult for black athletes to show injuries և the right to receive prizes.
A court hearing was scheduled for Thursday. Instead, the judge ordered the NFL $ $ 1 billion attorney general to settle the matter through mediation. It seems that this process will exclude the players of the CC who have filed a lawsuit.
“We are deeply concerned that the solution proposed by the Court is the following: to settle the negotiations with the parties who created this discriminatory system,” said lawyer Cyril V. “The class of former blackjack players we represent must have a place around the table and have a transparent process.”
Ent demographic factors that doctors consider when examining dementia often include racial race. If so, advocates say the test suggests that black athletes start out with better cognitive function than whites, which means they find it more difficult to show deficits. Both Henry and Davenport were denied the awards, but according to their lawsuits, they would have been lucky if they had been white.
Smith had hoped to find out the scope of the issue as the lawsuit was being pushed forward, but the dismissal of U.S. Senior Judge Anita B. Brody in Pennsylvania means she can never know how many SS players have lost their payouts due to practice.
He wants the NFL to ban race normalization and review cases if they have been used before.
An NFL spokesman did not immediately return comments seeking comment. The players’ chief lawyer, Christopher Seger, said the practice was not regulated as a result of the settlement, but remained at the discretion of the testing doctors.
“We oppose any complaints from the NFL in support of former players or doctors who have deemed it inappropriate to make such adjustments,” Seiger said in a statement.
Brody has been in charge since 2011 when the first players sued for claiming that the NFL had long since concealed what it knew about concussions. The judge was also conducting secret negotiations at the time, which led to a surprise settlement of the case long before the revelation or trial in 2013.
The fund has so far paid more than $ 765 million to retired players for neurocognitive problems related to NFL concussions, including about $ 335 million for dementia. Payments are expected to exceed $ 1 billion before the end of the 65-year settlement plan.
Allegations of dementia are particularly controversial. Many of them were rejected, often after NFL challenges.
League spokesman Brian McCarthy called the lawsuit “completely wrong” when it was filed last year.
The “settlement plan” was the result of a comprehensive negotiation between the NFL “Class Counsel”, approved by the federal courts after examining its fairness, and always considered the use of recognized statistical techniques to take into account demographic differences. such as age, education, race, “he said in a statement at the time.
Seger said he saw no evidence of racial bias in the settlement plan. Still, he said Monday, he regrets that he “opened a painful wound” for some.
Henry, who played for the Pittsburgh Steelers from 1993-2000, said his lawsuit was rejected despite suffering from headaches, depression and memory loss that prevented him from working.
Davenport, who played for the Steelers, the Green Bay Packers and the Indianapolis Colts from 2002 to 2008, said he had suffered more than 10 concussions, including one with a broken eye and was unconscious. : He won the award before the NFL appealed, asking that his test scores be recalculated using racial norms, Smith said. In the event of that measurement, his claim would fail.
Follow Maricler Dale on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Maryclairedale